The Agency Playbook, Part 5: Monitoring and Responding. What to Watch Daily, and What to Say When It Goes Wrong.
Check each client's Google listing every business day, reply to every review on a set deadline, and report only reviews that break Google's policies.
It's 7:40 on a Tuesday. A roofing client texts a screenshot: Google says they close at 3 p.m. on weekdays. They don't. Somebody snapped a photo of the sign from the old warehouse, Maps read the hours off it, and the "Does this look right?" email went to an inbox the owner hasn't opened since 2019. Meanwhile a one-star review titled "NEVER AGAIN" has been sitting unanswered for six days.
Neither is a disaster yet. Both become one when nobody's watching. This is Part 5 of The Agency Playbook, the seven-part series for people new to running reviews and local listings for local service businesses. Part 1 covered the job, Part 2 covered onboarding, Part 3 covered the rules, and Part 4 got reviews flowing. Now you watch all of it, and answer what comes in.
Why listings change while you sleep
Google's help page on Google updates to your Business Profile spells out the part agencies need to memorize. When a suggested edit needs review, the owner may get an email or an in-product notice, and then has 4 days to accept or reject it. Miss the window, and Google may publish the change anyway if other public info, such as the business website, supports it. Edits needed to meet policy can skip owner review entirely. Fields Google changed show up in blue in the profile editor.
The suggestions are also getting easier to make. In August, Google announced that people can suggest edits conversationally from Ask Maps and the Contribute tab, including uploading a photo of a storefront sign so Maps can read the hours. That feature, Tell Maps, is rolling out in the U.S. For the owner-side version of this story, send clients to customers can edit your Google listing.
One rule for agencies: Google's third-party policies say that automatically discarding suggested updates without consulting the merchant violates its terms. So no robot that rejects everything on sight.
Who watches which inbox
Most missed windows are a mail-routing problem. For every location, write down:
- Who gets Google's emails. If notices only reach the owner's personal Gmail, you're relying on someone who reads email at red lights. Get the agency added as a manager (see Part 2) so notices reach a shared inbox you check.
- Who's the backup. A named person, not "the team." Vacations don't pause a four-day clock.
- Who on the client side approves changes. Hours and phone numbers are quick calls. A category change or a "permanently closed" suggestion needs the owner's answer, in writing.
The monitoring cadence for a book of clients
A weekly audit is too slow for a four-day window. Split the work by frequency:
Every business day (15 minutes, coffee optional)
- Scan the shared inbox for Google notices and suggested edits. Log each with the date the window closes.
- Check for new reviews across every client, starting with anything at three stars or below.
- Look for blue fields on any profile that had a notice or a recent change.
Every week
- View each profile as a customer would: hours, phone, website, address or service area, categories.
- Clear the reply queue. Nothing older than your target should be left.
- Check special hours for upcoming holidays. Holiday weeks are when the storefront-sign photos start flying.
Every month
- Compare the website against the profile, field by field. Google may use the site to back up an edit, so a stale footer works against you.
- Check the status of any reviews you reported.
- Log what changed, what you caught, and what you answered. Part 6 turns that into a report.
Set response-time targets, and write them down
Google's review reply tips say to respond "in a timely manner" but don't name a number, so set your own and put it in the client agreement. A workable start: negative reviews answered within one business day, everything else within a few.
Two things to tell clients, per Google's manage reviews page: replies are checked against policy before posting (usually up to 10 minutes, sometimes up to 30 days), and the reviewer is notified when you reply and can still change their review.
Reply scripts for the reviews nobody wants to answer
Google's guidance: be polite and brief, protect privacy, apologize when it fits, and take complicated conversations offline. Here's how that sounds. For everyday replies, see these review reply scripts.
The one-star rant. Don't argue the details in public. Acknowledge, own what's fair, take it offline.
Hi Dana, we're sorry the install didn't go the way you expected, and we want to make it right. Please call our office manager, Luis, at the number on our profile so we can look at your job together. Thanks for telling us.
The "I've never seen this person" review. Stay calm, don't call anyone a liar, and report it if it breaks policy (more below).
Hi Chris, we can't find a visit or job under this name, and we'd like to understand what happened. Please reach out to us directly so we can look into it.
The review that's partly right. Agree with the true part out loud. Correct the rest gently, without a spreadsheet of evidence.
Thanks, Priya. You're right that the groomer ran 40 minutes late, and that's on us. We've changed how we book Saturday appointments. We're glad Biscuit came home looking great, and we hope to see you both again.
The three-star "it was fine." This one is an invitation. Answer it like one.
Thanks for the honest review, Marcus. If there's one thing that would have made your oil change a five-star visit, we'd really like to hear it. Just reply here or give us a call.
Never offer a discount in exchange for changing a review. Google's content policy prohibits incentives for revising or removing a negative review, and Part 3 explained what that costs.
When to flag a review, and when not to
You can report any review, but Google's page on reporting inappropriate reviews is clear: only reviews that violate its policies get removed, and you shouldn't report one just because you disagree with it. Flag fake reviews, conflicts of interest (a competitor or ex-employee), harassment, hate speech, profanity, personal information, and spam.
Evaluation typically takes several days. Track status in Google's Reviews Management Tool, which also allows a one-time appeal if a report comes back "no policy violation." Reply publicly while you wait.
One special case: a sudden pile of one- and two-star reviews followed by someone demanding money to remove them. Don't pay or negotiate. Collect screenshots and use Google's extortion scam reporting process.
When to escalate to the client
You answer the routine stuff. The client gets a same-day message, with your recommendation attached, when:
- A suggested edit touches the name, category, phone, address, or open/closed status.
- A review alleges something serious: safety, discrimination, damage, a legal threat, or a refund dispute.
- A review names an employee, or you'd need job records to answer it.
- You're about to report a review. They know their customers; you don't.
Keep it short: "Google suggested X. We recommend rejecting it because Y. Reply by Thursday." Log the answer.
Where AI drafts fit
Google now offers AI help for owners. Its help page on managing a Business Profile with Gemini says Gemini can draft replies, but only for people who own or manage a single verified profile, which rules out most agency accounts. Search Engine Land has reported Google testing AI reply suggestions inside the profile dashboard, too. Drafts are fine. Unread drafts are not.
For a book of clients, More Good Reviews brings each client's reviews into one agency account, sends new-review alerts, and drafts replies using instructions you set per location, so the landscaper's replies don't sound like the salon's. Just make sure a human reads anything under four stars before it posts.
The bottom line
Monitoring is a routine, not a heroic save. Route Google's emails to an inbox you actually check, triage notices and reviews every business day, keep websites and profiles matching, and ask the client before you accept or reject anything that matters. Answer every review on a deadline you've written down, flag only what breaks Google's policies, and escalate the hard ones early. Clients rarely notice the edit you caught. They always notice the one you didn't.
Next in The Agency Playbook: Part 6 covers reporting results and pricing your retainer: what goes in a monthly report, and how to package the work so it doesn't look like you're billing for "checking email."